Now Opening · July 6 – 9

Pull up a chair — the oven's already warm.

Famous calzones, baked hoagies, fresh salads, 9″ pizzas and more — the mom-and-pop Italian Butler County has loved for thirty years, back in Fairfield.

A photo of the Brown family — coming soon

Our Story

Thirty years. Three kitchens. One family.

My son Ben and I would like to introduce you to Paninos Primo Italiano. Our family has fed Butler County for more than thirty years — at Johnny's Deli in Oxford, DeCaro's on Pleasant in Fairfield, and All8Up in downtown Hamilton — and we couldn't be happier to be serving Fairfield again.

Calzones, baked hoagies, fresh salads, 9-inch pizzas, baked spaghetti — it's the food this community has loved for decades, and we still make it the same way: by hand, with care, the way family does.

Mom-and-pop service still exists at Paninos — come experience our “primo Italiano” taste.

— Tony & Ben Brown

From our daughter Abby's kitchen

Flower and Frost Bakery

Our daughter Abby runs Flower and Frost Bakery, and her cookies sell out fast. Baked fresh in her own kitchen and waiting right here at our counter — grab a few on your way out.

See the cookies

Online Ordering

Coming soon.

We open July 6–9, with online ordering to follow. For now, give us a call or stop by the counter — we'll have it hot and ready, and we'll save you a slice.

Order Online — Coming Soon

In the meantime, call us at (513) 555-0123.